pct 1.0 now supports Visual Studio project files and is multithreaded

The initial version of pct (0.1.0) still required a lot of configuration to auto-generate precompiled headers for large codebases and it was not as fast as some users would have liked (#4) . Version 1.0 addressed both shortcomings.

pct can now parse Visual Studio project files to extract information like the path of the include directories to search for headers or the macro values to use; so the new options –sln or –vcxproj save you from specifying a long command line . Users that use qmake or cmake just need to generate Visual Studio project files from their build files to able to use the tool in the same way (See Cross-platform development with C++).

Performance greatly improved after, by processing every .vcxproj in parallel with std::async(). It is not uncommon to have big codebases in C++, so this change was useful and easy to implement.

I recently realized that environment variables referenced in the Visual Studio project files were not being expanded. Qmake expanded them for me before generating the Visual Studio project files, so I did not realize this until now; but it was  fixed on 8d43ad1. I also added an option –excluderegexp which is useful for qmake users, because it could be used to ignore moc_* files (which do not need to be parsed by pct because all their headers are referenced already in the original moc’ed header). E.g. –excluderegexp “moc_.*”.



Cross-platform development with C++

I have been developing cross-platforms C++ applications for some years now. In this post I would like to share my experience on several aspects of C++ cross-platform development, mainly focusing on Windows and Linux and using Qt.

Build tools

Keeping your build project files (makefiles on unix, Visual Studio project files) in sync manually is a hassle and error prone task. To help with that I have tried several alternatives: cmake, qmake and bjam. I found that the easiest to use by far is qmake, part of the Qt toolkit.


qmake is my first choice when it comes to cross-platform development. It is not as powerful as cmake but its language is much simpler and concise. Imagine we would like to compile the helloworld program of my previous post. This qmake helloworld.pro file will suffice as build script:


The template app tells qmake we would like to build an application. By default, in Windows this means to creating an .exe file that runs on a console.

If we would like to use an IDE to build the project, we can just open the .pro file with QtCreator, or we are using Visual Studio we can actually generate the solution files from the command line.

Because Visual Studio has the concept of “solution”, a root file that points to different projects, we need to create an equivalent to the .sln file, in this case, a .pro file that point to the other .pro files. In our case, I created a helloworld_global.pro file:

TEMPLATE = subdirs

helloworld.subdir = helloworld
helloworld.target = helloworld
SUBDIRS += helloworld

which looks for a .pro file called helloworld in the helloworld folder. Then I was able to generate the VS project files with:

%QTDIR%\bin\qmake -r -spec win32-msvc2013 -tp vc Q
MAKE_CXXFLAGS+=/MP helloworld_global.pro

The spec specifies the pair platform/compiler version to use. In my case because the spec was win32-msvc2013 and I was using a x64 native tools command prompt this generated 64-bit Visual Studio 2013 solution, that could be opened with the file helloworld_global.sln.

Many of the features of qmake are very straightforward, including adding precompiled headers portably.

I do not recommend using the Visual Studio Qt wizards to manage the VS project files. I feel much more practical to use the .pro file as a single point of truth and then use the command line to generate the VS project files.


cmake is probably the most popular and powerful toolkit for building cross-platform C++ code.

Its syntax is a bit cumbersome (for instance because it does not have compound statements, so sometimes you have to explicitly mark which statement is being ended, i.e. if you have nested ifs you may need to specify which if you are actually closing of all the ifs that were opened).

cmake has a GUI which is very handy for inspecting and change the value of the cmake variables in a CMake build directory.


bjam is a nifty tool. It is a good idea to use it if you are generating Boost Python, as it will take care that all the compiler options that are needed to interface C++ with Python are actually used.  Unfortunately, it is not well-documented (when I used it, I had to look in the boost code which options where available).

Processes and threads

C++11 introduced added language support to multithreading to C++. If you are using a pre-C++11 compiler and still want portable threading you can use boost (which primitives are very similar to C++11) or Qt.

Unfortunately there is still not a way in the C++ language to create processes, as process handling is very different between systems. Nevertheless Qt includes QProcess which allows you to manage processes in a portable way.

Portable GUIs

I developed a GUI for C++ using GTK around 10 years ago. I used glade to generate the code, and I really liked it at the time. The callback code needed the use of a lot of macros used emulate a type hierarchy (GTK is C based), but I thought it was mainly clean and neat anyway.

Unfortunately, as of 2016, it seems that GTK does not seem to be so well supported outside of Linux, specially if compared with Qt. Many projects that used GTK have moved to Qt.

Qt is C++ based and has many features that are interesting for GUI development. For instance, it has internalization support; its widgets take into account that some languages are written right to left, some have several accents, some have ligatures… It also allows you create a XML repository of translations that you can query at runtime depending on the locales. E.g. this element in qt_es.ts (included in Qt itself):

<location line="+1"/>

Will instruct Qt to translate “File” to “Fichero”, when the Spanish/Spain locale is being used. E.g. the code:

QMenu *menu = new QMenu(menuBar);


will create a menu with the name “Fichero”. The macro tr() should be used for any string literal that could be displayed to the user, so the literal will be translated before displaying it.

Qt has also Android, iphone and Windows Phone support. For mobile development, Qt provides QML, a mark-up language which provides a good way to specify small user interfaces using a declarative language.

Compiler differences

Compilers implemented the C++11 standard at different speeds, and for some time this made the newest features in the standard not very portable. Fortunately, as of 2016, all the major compilers support C++11 almost in full.

There are still differences, though, the Visual Studio preprocessor is not standard compliant and fails when passing variadic data as a whole directly into a non-variadic macro.

Nevertheless Microsoft has promised to integrate the clang front-end in Windows as well, so in the future developing cross-platform C++ applications using Visual Studio should be completely hassle-free.

Subversion and end-of-line

Subversion is still probably the most popular centralized version control system. One problem it has when used in cross-platform development is that, by default, it does not pay attention to end of line markers. This means that, for example, if we commit a file on Linux and then check it out on a Windows machine, the editor may display the whole file in a single line, as it will not have carriage returns which the Windows programs expect.

The best solution to the problem is to use eol-style=native, that can be specified in subversion´s config file:

enable-auto-props = yes

*.cpp = svn:eol-style=native

This instructs svn to check out *.cpp files differently according to the platform. LF on UNIX and CRLF on Windows, the native end of line character on each one. We would need to do the same for every file extension that could cause problems.



Experimenting with modules in C++

One of the most awaited features of C++ are modules. One of the problems that modules addresses is that exactly the same headers files are compiled again and again during C++ developments (and some of them like <iostream> , could be extremely big). Caching those compilations will speed up compilation times dramatically.

Modules, in the LLVM implementation, are a generalization of precompiled headers. Precompiled headers are implemented by all the major C++ compiler vendors and they are simply a way of storing the compiler state to disk, so if a .cpp file has an associated precompiled header, the compiler can use this stored state to “fast forward” its state to the one it had after compiling the precompiled header, and skip the compilation of some headers. Because they are just storing the whole compiler state, only one precompiled header can be used per .cpp file.

Although precompiled headers could reduce compilation times dramatically, especially on Windows (where I experienced one order of magnitude improvement on one of my projects when I enabled them), they usually required a lot of manual work and they increase the chances of name collisions as they are usually shared by many files.

The latest versions of clang featured modules. Modules are a much better solution to reduce build times. They store the resulting Abstract Syntax Trees after the parsing of a header, that can be added incrementally to the current compiler state, instead of the whole state. Thusly, multiple modules can be loaded when compiling a translation unit, and a module’s header will be parsed once per language configuration rather than every time a dependant translation unit is recompiled.

Even if we do not use modules in our code, a module-enabled compiler like clang will still be faster than a traditional compiler, because it will still make use of one module, the std, skipping the textual inclusion of standard headers and using their binary representation instead.

You will need the LLVM suite, the clang compiler, the libc++ standard library and the libcxxabi to be able to experiment with modules. Because I wanted to experiment with the latest version, I checked out the trunk of all those projects, but the binary bundles of LLVM 3.7 have modules as well, so you may use them instead. I compiled the whole thing out of the source tree with:

cmake -DLLVM_PATH=../llvm -DLIBCXX_CXX_ABI=libcxxabi -DLIBCXX_CXX_ABI_INCLUDE_PATHS=../llvm/projects/libcxxabi/include -DCMAKE_C_COMPILER=clang -DCMAKE_CXX_COMPILER=clang++ ../llvm/projects/libcxx


(note: for some reason a parallel build with make -j of llvm crash gcc on my machine so executed my build serially, but that is probably something wrong my version of gcc, 4.8.4)

Then I tried this simple example, which just makes use of the std module:

#include <iostream>
using namespace std;

int main()
cout &lt;&lt; &quot;Hello, world!!!&quot;;
return 0;
gerardo@GOLIATH:~/llvm_tests$ time clang++ -fmodules -fcxx-modules -fmodules-cache-path=./cache_path -stdlib=libc++ -lc++abi -L/home/gerardo/llvm.libcxxabi.release/lib helloworld.cpp

real    0m2.213s
user    0m2.148s
sys    0m0.064s

This is the first time I created the cache, which entails compiling the whole standard library and thus the long compilation times. If we go to ./cache_path:

total 4
drwxrwx--- 2 gerardo gerardo 4096 Sep 13 16:37 D9DWX79PA5LV
-rw-rw-r-- 1 gerardo gerardo    0 Sep 13 16:37 modules.timestamp&amp;amp;lt;/code&amp;amp;gt;

total 10144
-rw-rw-r-- 1 gerardo gerardo   225476 Sep 13 16:37 modules.idx
-rw-rw-r-- 1 gerardo gerardo 10154840 Sep 13 16:37 std-2WRNL6O46F2FW.pcm

we can see that a module std was compiled in the file std-2WRNL6O46F2FW.pcm.

(Note: on my machine I got this error:

/usr/local/bin/../include/c++/v1/future:515:23: error: a non-type template parameter cannot have type 'std::__1::future_errc'

when clang was generating the std module. I guess this is just a bug in the trunk that will be fixed soon. I disabled the module future at /usr/local/include/c++/v1/module.modulemap and the generation of module std worked)

Subsequent compilations are much faster, thanks to the module cache:

gerardo@GOLIATH:~/llvm_tests$ time clang++ -fmodules -fcxx-modules -fmodules-cache-path=./cache_path -stdlib=libc++ -lc++abi -L/home/gerardo/llvm.libcxxabi.release/lib helloworld.cpp&amp;amp;lt;/code&amp;amp;gt;

real    0m0.093s
user    0m0.080s
sys    0m0.014s

If we want to create our own modules, we have to use the module map language. For example, this module.modulemap file creates a module that exposes the C++ header “myheader.h”

module test {
requires cplusplus
header &quot;myheader.h&quot;;